Editor's note: This is the first of a two-part series.
DICKINSON CENTER, N.Y. - How would you like to hunt Canada-sized deer
without having to go all the way to Canada or pay Canada-hunt prices?
"If you drive around here during the rut to the places where they're
having bug buck contests, I'm telling you you'll see deer hanging
that are every bit as big as Saskatchewan deer," said Anthony Platoni,
owner of BuckLore Hunting Adventures.

BuckLore operates in the foothills of the Adirondacks, 20 miles from
the Canada border, about an hour northwest of Lake Placid. Hunts are
conducted in St. Lawrence and Franklin counties, which are two of
New York's northernmost counties.
It's an eight-hour drive from Lancaster County, and BuckLore's fully-guided
deer hunts this year went for $850 for five days hunting, with lodging
and three meals per day that are fit for a king. Next year the hunts
will cost $950, but that's still a bargain.
You pretty much have to fly into Saskatchewan, where deer hunts average
$3,000.
So why haven't you heard of deer hunting in northern New York like
you have in Saskatchewan?
Good question. I never heard of it either, until this year.
When my hunting buddy Tom Tatum called me last year and asked if I
wanted to join him on a weeklong bowhunt the first week of October
this fall in northern New York, I said, "Where?"
"Nobody knows about this area," said Platoni, who has operated BuckLore
since 1997 with his companion, Dolores Rice. "Everybody knows about
deer hunting in Canada, bear hunting in Maine and turkey hunting in
southern New York. We've got all that right here and the hunting is
just as good, if not better, than it is in those other places."
After my recent bowhunt with BuckLore, I believe it won't be long
before northern New York becomes the newest "have-to-go-there" destination
on North America's hunting map.
And since BuckLore is one of the only guide services in the region,
they are gatekeepers to this land of opportunity.
*
The foothills of the Adirondacks in northern New York is a sparsely
populated area.
|
There are some working farms. There seem to be even more abandoned
farms.
"You have six months of hard winter here," Platoni said. "And I mean
hard. You have several days each year that are 40 below. A lot of
people move up here, and then realize that they can't stand the winters."
The landscape resembles Canadian bush country. The forest vegetation
is thick and the trees aren't very tall.
Tatum and I took our climbing tree stands on the trip, even though
Platoni said we probably wouldn't be able to use them. "We don't have
trees suitable for climbing stands," he said.
When we saw the timber, we immediately realized he was right. The
trees were too short and the forests were too thick, so we hunted
from Platoni's ladder and hanging stands posted on field edges.
Even if we found a tree to climb, we couldn't have climbed more than
15 feet or we wouldn't have been able to see more than 10 feet in
any direction.
Big country, lots of cover, few people, harsh winters. That's a recipe
for growing big deer anywhere.
Add to those factors, Platoni said, a host of predators, including
black bears, bobcats and coyotes, that love venison.
"Our deer are healthy," Platoni said. "If they're not, they get eaten
by something. You don't see wounded or skinny deer around here."
The largest deer ever shot by a BuckLore hunter tipped the scales
at 240 pounds, dressed. That's a 300-pounder on the hoof.
"We have bigger ones, too," Platoni said. "But you don't see them
every day."
One of the first things Platoni and Rice realized when they opened
shop was that it's hard for visiting hunters to pursue mammoth bucks
after driving past field after field of big deer.
Platoni said there are plenty of magazine-cover bucks living on the
thousands of acres he either owns or leases, but it takes a determined
hunter to bag one.
He has a rack from such a buck hanging on the wall of the guest lodge.
The bases of the antlers are about as thick as the handle of a baseball
bat and the mass carries throughout the rack. Many points stick out
in all directions.
"Those deer live in the swamps," he said. "There aren't a whole lot
of deer there, so you might sit for a whole week and see three deer,
But when you see a buck, it's usually a real hog."
To appease most deer hunters, Platoni leases farm fields where the
deer aren't quite as big, but are far more numerous.
|
"It's easier for a guy to sit on a stand when he's seeing 20 deer
every time he goes out," he said.
St. Lawrence County in 2002 and 2001 ranked fourth among all counties
in new York for its buck kill - 5,664 last year and 6,161 the year
before.
The three counties ahead of St. Lawrence are all in the extreme southwest
corner of the state abutting Pennsylvania.
*
Platoni and Rice didn't just stumble into the fine hunting country
of northern New York for their BuckLore operation.
The couple studied many parts of the U.S. while they lived in West
Chester in the mid 1990s.
An avid archer, Rice operated a graphic arts business out of her home
in the Chester County borough. She designed the business logo for
Lancaster Archery Supply when she lived and worked in the area.
Platoni worked as a taxidermist after owning his own restaurant in
Virginia and working as a chef for Marriot hotels. (The latter explains
the fantastic dining at BuckLore).
During their search for a home for their dream guide-service operation,
the two quickly zeroed in on Maine, Minnesota and northern New York,
because part of the business had to include bear hunting.
Platoni is a bona fide bear nut.
"Bears are the smartest animals in the woods, no question," he said.
"You have to be totally committed to get a bear.
Fortunately for BuckLore's bear hunters, Platoni is totally committed.
He's the reason for their success.
Rice said Platoni starts baiting his bear stands in April so that
the animals are conditioned to frequent those areas come the September
hunting season.
"First he goes every three days, then every other day, then every
day as the season gets closer," she said. "He really works hard at
it."
Last month, 11 BuckLore hunters killed 10 bears - the largest weighing
400 pounds.
"It was a good season," Platoni said.
The deer season in New York's north zone runs from Sept. 27 through
Oct. 17 for archery; Oct. 11-17 and Dec. 8-14 for muzzleloader; and
Oct. 18 through Dec. 7 for rifle.
BuckLore books hunts for all three seasons. For information on the
operation, go to www.bucklore.com or call Platoni at (518) 856-0138.
Next Week: My bowhunt for a
trophy, northern New York buck.
|